Commercial value, redefined

Updated: 5 days ago
‘’ Commercial value is described through capacity released, cost reduced or avoided, risk removed, service improved, decisions made faster and resilience increased,’’ Laura Robey.
Why read this Leadership interview
Commercial leadership is often misunderstood as cost cutting but ‘’ Commercial value is described through capacity released, cost reduced or avoided, risk removed, service improved, decisions made faster and resilience increased,’’ Laura Robey.
Why read this Leadership interview
Commercial leadership is often misunderstood as cost cutting but Laura Robey blows that myth apart.
In this interview she explains why true commercial maturity means holding cost, risk, service, people and long(er) term value together, even when the choices are uncomfortable. She shares powerful real‑world examples including a £3m MOD savings to leading through Middle East aviation disruption, which shows how workforce capability, crisis clarity, supplier partnerships and transformation all shape commercial outcomes.
If you want to understand what commercial leadership really looks like in practice, this conversation is essential reading.
Commercial Leadership Interview with Laura Robey
PJ: Laura, let’s start at the heart of it. When you think about commercial leadership, not in theory but in real life, what does it actually mean?
Laura: For me, commercial leadership is about understanding the full consequences of a decision and not just the cost. People often assume commercial means ‘spend less’, but that’s far too narrow. Sometimes the cheapest option creates greater operational risk, can damage service or stores up a much larger cost later. Equally, caring about people doesn’t mean avoiding difficult financial decisions. Mature commercial leadership is being able to hold cost, risk, service, people and long‑term value together, and remain accountable for the decision.
I learned this early in my career. When I led the safe disposal of defunct RAF/MOD equipment during the Basra extraction, the goal wasn’t simply to dispose of assets cheaply. It had to be safe, responsible and represent genuine public value. We delivered £3 million in savings, but the real achievement was balancing safety, responsibility and value simultaneously. That mindset still applies today in my work, in my previous role in the cruise industry, if the right crew aren’t available, capable and ready at the right time, the consequences are operational, commercial and human.
Commercial leadership is not cost first…. it’s value, consequences and sustainability understood together.
PJ: When you’re making those decisions, especially ones that affect people, culture and service, what’s the hardest part?
Laura: The hardest part is accepting that there is rarely… never… a perfect answer. Leadership often means choosing between competing consequences rather than between something clearly right and clearly wrong. You might be balancing cost against care, pace against inclusion, resilience against individual experience … or short‑term continuity against retaining capability for the future.
My role is often to ensure the human impact doesn’t become a footnote in the commercial case. But I also have to help people understand the operational and financial reality … not pretend every desired outcome is possible.
I use three tests:
• Is the decision necessary and supported by evidence?
• Have we genuinely considered the impact on people, service and operations?
• Could I explain the decision honestly to someone directly affected and stand behind the process?
Culture isn’t tested when decisions are popular….. but it is tested when the organisation is under pressure. People may not agree with the final outcome, but trust can still be protected through fairness, dignity, clarity and honest communication. You can’t always protect people from a difficult outcome, but you can protect fairness, dignity and trust in how that outcome is reached, I'm a people centred leader and will come back to this time and time again, there are people at the heart of HR decisions and can we honestly say we have taken steps to ensure the decisions were well thought out and defendable.
PJ: You’ve worked across huge, complex operating models. Where do organisations misunderstand the link between people decisions and commercial outcomes?
Laura: Many organisations treat people decisions as something that follows the business strategy. In reality, workforce capability is part of the business strategy.
In maritime operations, recruiting someone doesn’t mean usable capability is available. Medicals, documentation, visas, travel, training, role competence, onboarding and personal readiness all have to align. A failure at any point creates additional flights, vacancies, acting up arrangements, overtime, management effort and pressure on colleagues already onboard.
Another mistake is measuring activity rather than value. Filling a vacancy quickly may look successful, but not if the individual is unprepared, leaves early or requires substantial intervention before becoming effective.
Better measures include:
• time to productivity rather than only time to hire
• workforce readiness rather than recruitment completion
• continuity rather than simple headcount
• colleague and operational outcomes rather than process compliance
Having worked across an operating model supporting around 19,000 crew, I can say confidently that what is often described as ‘people administration’ is actually critical operational and commercial control. People decisions aren’t a support activity alongside the business model …. they are part of the business model, its workforce planners and leaders job to articulate this risk and foresight to senior business leaders to make sure its tabled at appropriate levels.
PJ: Let’s talk about disruption and crisis. What does commercially smart leadership look like when everything is moving fast and imperfectly?
Laura: Commercially smart leadership under pressure starts by agreeing what must be protected. During major aviation disruption affecting crew movements through the Middle East, we were dealing with changing information, constrained supplier options, immovable operational deadlines and substantial cost exposure.
My role was to gather the team and create one reliable view of the situation, identify the most critical movements, establish clear escalation and decision rhythms, work actively with suppliers to preserve options, and make both operational risks and financial consequences visible to senior leaders.
Commercially smart crisis leadership looks like:
• clarity about non‑negotiables and priorities
• early escalation that preserves options
• active supplier engagement and honest cost visibility
• disciplined decisions with imperfect information
It does not look like chasing the cheapest transaction while increasing enterprise risk, waiting for perfect information, hiding uncomfortable costs, or allowing every stakeholder to treat their issue as the highest priority.
Calm leadership matters. Calm doesn’t mean passive, it means creating enough structure for people to make good decisions at speed, allowing mistakes, re-direction and a safe space for people to speak up, as that one little idea from someone could unlock a whole new pathway to fix a problem. I've seen this so many times when someone says “sorry this maybe a stupid idea, but” or “sorry can I ask a question”. Often these are the ones that change the playing field. If you’re at the table you have voice, bring it, use it and we will all listen, this is what I will always try and foster.
PJ: Partnerships are a huge part of commercial leadership. What makes a partnership genuinely commercial rather than just contractual?
Laura: A contract records what the parties agreed. A genuinely commercial partnership determines whether the relationship continues to create value as circumstances change.
Five elements matter:
• shared outcomes
• transparency
• measurable accountability
• constructive tension
• continuous value
I once managed six Global Talent Acquisition Contracts whose fee structures, performance and risks were difficult to compare. I introduced benchmarking, comparable unit costs, due diligence, risk mapping and structured governance. The aim was to understand which suppliers created value, where risk existed and what intervention each relationship required. From this we managed to build relationships that supported the ROI we wanted and reflected what we were paying on the balance sheet.
Business intelligence shows what is happening. Strong relationships help you understand why. Effective governance turns that understanding into decisions and action.
PJ: Finally…. transformation. How do you show that commercial thinking isn’t just cost cutting?
Laura: I start transformation by being clear about the problem we’re trying to solve. Too many programmes begin with a preferred system, structure or savings target rather than the business outcome required.
For example, within People Operations, I have led and worked on process redesign using RPA, workflow automation, AI and integrated dashboards.the purpose was reliability, scalability and user‑focused service, not simply reducing overheads but making people’s jobs easier, data more reliable and ultimately better decision making and evidence based action. The key is to get buy in for the new process, model or thing you are redesigning and train people on how and why to use it. I've seen many a new dashboard suite get built and rolled out, using valuable time and money and then never be used! This can be prevented by understanding the why, who and what will it fix and improve and then communicate, communicate.... communicate.
And lastly, duplication. I've seen different teams within the same organisation trying to solve exactly the same problem, sometimes without even knowing what the other team is doing. Commercially, that's crazy.
You're wasting time, money, resource and people's energy. But there's another consequence that's often overlooked, and that's the impact on people. Imagine spending weeks working on a project, investing your ideas and enthusiasm, only to discover it's been stopped because another team is already doing exactly the same thing.
That's incredibly frustrating and demotivating. Organisations need better visibility, coordination and governance around change, so that people aren't unknowingly competing with each other or duplicating effort.
I've seen something similar when transferring workforce activity to offshore partners. It's not simply about moving work to a lower-cost location and declaring a saving. You have to design the operating model properly. That means being clear about processes, decision rights, controls, training, performance measures and, importantly, building stakeholder confidence that the new arrangement will actually work.
This is where genuine commercial thinking comes in.
I believe commercial value can be described through six things - capacity released, cost reduced or avoided, risk removed, service improved, decisions made faster and resilience increased.
If you can articulate how a decision delivers even some of those outcomes, you're demonstrating real commercial thinking. You're looking beyond the immediate price tag and understanding the wider value to the organisation.
And if the bottom line is the priority, that's absolutely fine. Sometimes businesses have to make decisions that come down to cost. But even then, you should be able to connect the decision back to the business priorities and strategy.
It's about being able to say: "If we do this, we get that"
That's the difference between simply cutting costs and making commercially intelligent decisions.
Cost cutting asks what can be removed. Commercial transformation asks what capability the organisation needs and the most sustainable way to deliver it.
Should you wish to discuss anything that triggers your thinking from this article, please DM me, or use the old fashioned phone.
___________________________________________________
4 top takeaways for my convo with Laura
1. Commercial leadership is about creating value.
Laura challenges one of the biggest myths in business. Strong commercial leaders balance cost, risk, service, people and long term value together. The cheapest option is not always the smartest option.
2. Workforce capability is a commercial issue, not an HR issue.
Organisations often treat people decisions as a support function. Laura argues the opposite. Readiness, capability and continuity directly affect operational performance, customer outcomes and commercial results.
3. Great leaders make tough decisions without sacrificing trust.
The real test of leadership comes under pressure. Even when outcomes are difficult, trust can be maintained through fairness, dignity, evidence based decisions and honest communication.
4. Transformation should focus on capability rather than headcount reduction.
Commercial transformation is about improving resilience, service, speed, scalability and decision making. Cost savings may follow, but they should not be the primary goal.
My most memorable quote
"Commercial value is described through capacity released, cost reduced or avoided, risk removed, service improved, decisions made faster and resilience increased."
For me, this reframes commercial success in a way that most leaders might like to (re)consider.
CTA for Leaders
Want to become a stronger (commercial) leader?
Start by challenging every major decision through a broader lens.
Ask yourself: Are we creating sustainable value by balancing people, risk, service and long term outcomes?
I suggest that leaders who master that balance build organisations that perform today and are more likely to remain resilient tomorrow





Comments