The Seven Commercial Mistakes Smart Organisations Keep Making

Why successful businesses drift towards entropy and what leaders can do about it
When you work inside large organisations, you quickly learn that businesses naturally slide into disorder unless someone keeps them honest. It’s the corporate version of the second law of thermodynamics, everything drifts towards mess, waste and complacency unless leadership applies pressure.
That’s why the first 10% of savings in any outsourcing / tech deal never come from clever tech or bold investment. They come from setting clear targets, measuring performance properly and holding people accountable. Remove that discipline and entropy rushes straight back in.
David told me that he once had a senior manager tell me, as he was being brought back in‑house, “I guess this means we don’t need to bother with all those KPIs anymore.” He wasn’t joking. He was relieved. And that’s the point: without scrutiny, standards decay … fast.
Here's the highlights and top tips from my conversation with Dr David Leabeater, friend, mentor and tech sales director….
1. BAU vs commercial discipline … the comfort trap
Theme: Too much BAU, not enough challenge or fresh thinking.
Expansion: Most organisations drift into Business as Usual because it’s comfortable, familiar and low‑risk to them….but commercial performance lives outside comfort. BAU becomes a hiding place or a way to stay busy without being fully effective. BAU persists when good enough is … good enough.
David notes that, "The greatest threat to performance isn't failure, it's comfort. Most organisations don't get beaten by competitors, they slowly get beaten by their own routines."
Commercial leaders challenge their team, and themselves, by asking:
What should we stop doing?
What’s the opportunity cost of staying comfortable?
Where are we avoiding the uncomfortable conversations or decisions?
What do our junior colleagues want from us that would help them to do their job better?
The duality is ……….. BAU = comfort. Commercial = discomfort.
And growth only happens in the second zone.
2. Lack of commercial discipline … activity over outcomes
Theme: Too many businesses lack discipline …and indiscipline snowballs.
Expansion: Commercial discipline means making decisions based on value, margin, risk and opportunity --- not habit, preference or internal politics. Without discipline, people default to effort-based thinking (eg we worked hard) instead of outcome-based thinking (… we created value). Not only does indiscipline at the top affect everyone, it sets the standard for management at all levels.
"Businesses rarely have an effort problem. They have a focus problem. People are busy everywhere; the question is whether they're busy doing things that create value."
Signs of weak commercial discipline:
No clear priorities
No commercial criteria for decision-making
People doing what they like, not what the business needs
Leaders avoiding tough calls because they’re socially uncomfortable
Commercial discipline is the backbone of commercial performance.
3. Treat clients like clients … not friends
Theme: Don’t treat clients like friends or you avoid the difficult conversations.
Expansion: Friendship-based client relationships feel warm but often block commercial clarity. When leaders avoid challenging clients on scope, price, expectations, or behaviour, they leak value.
"The moment you value being liked more than being honest, you've stopped serving the client properly."
Commercial relationships require:
Boundaries
Courage
Clarity
The ability to say “no”, “not yet”, or “that’s out of scope”
If you can’t have difficult conversations, you can’t be commercial.
4. Commerciality requires discomfort - doing what’s uncomfortable
Theme: Need to do things that feel uncomfortable.
Expansion: Commercial thinking is inherently uncomfortable because it forces people to confront:
Risk
Trade-offs
Prioritisation
Value leakage
Their own assumptions
Their own avoidance
"Commercial value is often hidden behind an uncomfortable conversation, an unpopular decision or a difficult trade-off."
Is the uncomfortable work actually the commercial work? If it feels too easy, it’s probably BAU.
5. Fresh ideas as a commercial imperative
Theme: How do you bring fresh ideas to your business… or don’t you?
Expansion: Commercial organisations generate and test new ideas constantly, new propositions, new pricing, new partnerships and new ways of working. Stagnant organisations rely on legacy thinking and legacy behaviours.
"Innovation is a commercial necessity. Standing still is usually just decline moving slowly enough not to notice," warns David.
Fresh ideas matter commercially because they:
Create new value
Open new markets
Improve margin
Differentiate from competitors
Prevent complacency
If you’re not bringing fresh ideas, you’re not being commercial… you are maintaining status quo.
6. Objective commercial criteria , the missing framework
Theme: Businesses need objective criteria to be more commercial.
Expansion: Without clear commercial criteria and focus, people can default to personal preference, politics or BAU. Commercial criteria act like a decision filter, helping teams choose what matters and ignore what doesn’t.
Here’s Davids view , "When organisations lack objective criteria, decisions tend to be made by whoever has the strongest opinion, not the strongest argument."
Examples of commercial criteria:
Margin thresholds
Customer value drivers
Strategic priorities
Risk appetite
Capacity constraints
ROI expectations
Pricing discipline
Opportunity cost
Commerciality requires a shared, objective framework, not subjective judgement.
7. Requirements engineering … the hidden commercial weakness
Theme: Organisations can’t articulate what they want, so they can’t get their needs met.
Expansion: This was one of David’s strongest observations. Organisations often assume failed projects, poor supplier performance or disappointing outcomes are caused by technology, capability or execution. In reality, the problem frequently starts much earlier because they never defined the requirement properly in the first place.
As David put it, "Most organisations think they have a technology problem. More often than not, they have a requirements problem."
If a business cannot clearly articulate:
What it wants
Why it wants it
What success looks like
What constraints exist
What trade-offs are acceptable
…then suppliers, partners, and internal teams cannot deliver commercially successful outcomes.
Poor requirements equals wasted money, wasted time, misaligned expectations and commercial failure / loss.
Better requirements engineering is a commercial capability, not a technical one.
Why it matters commercially:
It reduces rework
It improves supplier performance
It speeds up decision-making
It protects margin
It prevents scope creep
It ensures the business gets what it actually needs, not what someone guesses
Most organisations think they have a tech problem. They actually have a requirements problem.
Dr David Leabeater’s ‘ Big Commercial Insights’
Commerciality is not about being ‘business minded’. It’s about being disciplined, uncomfortable, clear and value-driven.
The organisations that struggle commercially are the ones that:
Stay in BAU
Avoid discomfort
Don’t challenge clients
Don’t bring fresh ideas
Fail to define objective commercial criteria
Can’t articulate what they want
Let people hide in activity instead of value
The organisations that excel commercially are likely to be the ones that:
Make decisions based on value, margin, risk, and opportunity
Have tough conversations early
Engineer clear requirements
Prioritise ruthlessly
Challenge BAU
Reward commercial thinking, not effort
Embrace discomfort as a performance lever
----------------------------
Over to you.
The reality is that most organisations have a wealth of knowledge, creativity and talent, yet they fail because they tolerate ambiguity, avoid discomfort and allow entropy to win.
So here's my challenge to senior leaders, owners and directors:
Take a hard look at your business this week and ask:
What are we doing because it creates value?
What are we doing simply because we've always done it?
Where are we accepting activity instead of outcomes?
What difficult conversation would unlock the most value if we had it today?
The answers may tell you more about your commercial performance than any dashboard will.
I'd genuinely welcome your thoughts, experiences and disagreements on this and other points from Dr David Leabeater and myself.
Comment below, challenge the ideas, add your own insights or connect with me directly.





Comments