top of page
Search

Curiosity is vital for Commerciality

Writer: PJ Stevens
PJ Stevens
Nov 2
8 min read

Why the best Businesses look beyond the numbers

An interview with Tim Foster, former BDO Partner, on commercial thinking, curiosity, leadership behaviours and unlocking the value already within an organisation.

Being commercial is about much more than understanding the numbers. It is about how people think, the questions they ask, the decisions they make and their ability to turn ideas into measurable value. Yet many organisations continue to constrain commercial thinking through their culture, leadership behaviours and everyday ways of working.

In this interview I spoke with to Tim Foster, who brings some 30 years of business experience, including 13 years as a partner at BDO, about what commerciality really means, why he believes curiosity is a competitive advantage and why overlooking the people factor can undermine even the best business strategies.

 

Commerciality has evolved beyond the numbers

PJ Stevens: Tim, you've spent decades working with businesses, finance functions and leadership teams. How has the meaning of being commercial evolved?


Tim Foster: Historically, commerciality has often been interpreted quite narrowly. If you understood the numbers, controlled costs, managed budgets and could demonstrate a financial return, you were considered commercial.


Those things still matter. But I think commerciality today needs to mean something much broader.


Being commercial means understanding how an organisation creates value, what could prevent it from creating that value, and what is required to sustain it.

That means understanding customers and markets, but it also means understanding your people and their capabilities, the capacity available to deliver, the technology that enables the organisation, and, critically, its ability to execute.


I've seen plenty of business cases where the financial argument stacks up beautifully on paper, but the organisation simply doesn't have the capability or capacity to deliver what the business case assumes.


If the organisation can't execute the plan, how commercial was the thinking in the first place?


PJ Stevens: So commerciality is as much about a way of thinking as it is about financial expertise?


Tim Foster: Absolutely. It's a mindset that needs to be embedded throughout the organisation. It isn't something reserved for the board, finance department or senior management.


I've worked with junior colleagues who demonstrated exceptional commercial judgement. They questioned proposed plans, challenged how we engaged with clients and considered whether the services we were providing genuinely met clients' needs. Sometimes, they challenged my thinking, too.


That ability to look beyond the immediate task and consider the wider business implications is what makes someone commercially valuable.


Curiosity is the missing ingredient in commercial thinking

PJ : You believe curiosity is fundamental to commerciality. Why do you think organisations struggle to encourage or develop it?


Tim: One thing I've become increasingly conscious of over the last five or six years is how important curiosity is to commercial thinking . For me, the two go hand in hand.


Commercially minded people ask questions. Why am I doing this? Why are we engaging with this customer in this particular way? What does the customer gain? What does this mean for the organisation? Is there a better way?


The problem is that many organisations are structured around a transactional mentality, meaning, get on with the job, complete the task, press the button and move on.


People are often assessed on delivering their immediate responsibilities, rather than necessarily being encouraged to challenge the process, explore alternatives or identify opportunities to improve the business.


The many CFOs I have spoken to want their people to be more curious and challenge more constructively. But wanting that behaviour and creating the conditions for it are two different things.


And this isn't just a finance issue. You want people in HR to understand what the business does and why. You want people in a warehouse to understand how their work contributes to the organisation's success. Every function has opportunities to think more commercially.


Leadership must reward the behaviours it wants to see

PJ : What do leaders need to do differently to build a culture of curiosity?


Tim : First, they need to give it attention and make it a priority. Leadership by example is critical.


They also need to reward curiosity appropriately. That doesn't necessarily mean financial rewards. It could mean giving people time to explore an idea, recognising a constructive challenge or celebrating the impact someone has had by asking a different question.

The important thing is consistency.


Organisations often tell people to challenge, but then punish failure. They say they encourage collaboration, but reward individuals solely on their personal performance.

When something goes wrong, people revert to familiar behaviours. The focus becomes getting the immediate task done, and the opportunity to collaborate, learn and improve disappears.


I believe that those are precisely the moments when curiosity and collaboration are most valuable. If you're trying to get out of a difficult situation, you need people connecting, thinking together, questioning assumptions and finding better solutions.


PJ :  So there's a disconnect between the behaviours leaders say they want and the behaviours their systems actually encourage?


Tim : Exactly. You can't tell people to think differently while creating an environment that discourages them from doing so.


If leaders want greater commercial ownership, they must examine how they measure performance, allocate time, respond to mistakes and recognise contributions. Culture isn't simply what appears on a set of corporate values. Culture is what people experience every day.


Technology won't deliver value without people

PJ : You've also worked extensively in advisory and transformation. Where do organisations unintentionally block commercial thinking?


Tim : One of the biggest challenges is underestimating the people side of the equation.

Organisations often invest heavily in technology, improving processes and introducing new systems because they expect these changes to deliver growth, efficiency or better control. But they don't always give sufficient attention to the people who must make those changes work.


You can give someone a Ferrari, but if they've only ever driven a moped, they're unlikely to get the full capability out of it.


The same applies to technology. Implementing a sophisticated system doesn't automatically mean people have the skills, confidence or capacity to use it effectively.

Organisations need to bring people on the journey, develop their capabilities and involve them early enough to make a meaningful contribution.


I've seen businesses move rapidly into transformation without allowing sufficient time for their own people to get involved. They subsequently bring in contractors or third parties, when internal employees might have been able to contribute if they had the time, skills and opportunity.


This isn't an argument against external expertise. It's about recognising the potential that already exists within the organisation and making deliberate choices about how to develop and use it.


Three commercial disciplines every leadership team should master

PJ : If you were coaching a leadership team today, which commercial disciplines would you insist they develop?


Tim : Personally, I'd focus on three areas.

First, embed financial planning and analysis (FP&A) thinking across the business.

FP&A shouldn't simply be a specialist finance activity focused on budgets, forecasts and financial analysis. The mindset behind good FP&A should be part of how managers across the organisation think and make decisions.


That means looking beyond today's numbers. What are they telling us? Where are we heading? What assumptions are we making? What could change? And what are the financial and commercial consequences of the decisions we're making today?


You don't need every manager to become an FP&A specialist, but you do want them to think in a more forward-looking, financially informed and commercially aware way.


Second, promote curiosity throughout the organisation.

As we've discussed, people need the time and encouragement to question how things are done, identify opportunities and challenge assumptions constructively.


This requires more than telling employees to be curious. Leaders must create the space for it, recognise its contribution and ensure people aren't penalised for raising legitimate questions.


Third, develop a clear understanding of resources, capability and value.

Leaders need to know whether their teams have the right skills and sufficient capacity to deliver their objectives. This is especially important during transformation, when organisations can underestimate the effort required to implement change while maintaining business-as-usual activities.


They must also define what value means for their organisation and communicate it clearly.

Value isn't simply pounds and pence. Different stakeholders may value different outcomes, and employees need to understand what the organisation is trying to achieve and why.


Where organisations communicate their purpose and value effectively, I've seen strong employee engagement and ownership. Where that clarity is missing, people can become disengaged because they don't understand why decisions are being made or how those decisions make sense.


Getting these three disciplines right can significantly strengthen commercial thinking across the business.


What separates technical competence from commercial excellence?

PJ : You've worked with many technically accomplished professionals. What differentiates those who are commercially exceptional?


Tim : Technically strong people are often very good at their particular discipline. They understand the detail, have the qualifications and can interpret complex information.

But some remain within their own area of expertise. They don't necessarily step back to consider the wider implications.


The exceptional ones take their technical knowledge and apply it pragmatically. They ask the right questions, look beyond the immediate problem and consider how their decisions affect the organisation as a whole.


They also have the confidence to challenge assumptions, even when they're unsure whether their question will be well received.


Importantly, the technically perfect answer isn't always the best commercial answer. Doing something strictly by the book doesn't automatically mean it's the right decision for the organisation.


Commercial judgement involves understanding the technical position, considering the broader context and weighing up the practical consequences.


A lot of that comes from curiosity: taking what you know and asking, "What if?" What if circumstances change? What would the impact be? What are we assuming? What else should we consider?


That is how technical expertise becomes a source of wider business value.


The biggest commercial risk? Underestimating people

PJ : What's the single biggest commercial risk you believe businesses are underestimating today?


Tim : For me, it's the people factor.

Organisations make major decisions about technology, processes, acquisitions and growth because they believe those decisions are commercially right. They may conduct extensive due diligence, examining whether systems can integrate, processes can operate together and business models can be combined.


But how thoroughly do they examine the cultural and human implications?


When two businesses come together, do their people understand the rationale? Will their cultures work together? Do employees have the capability and capacity to make the new organisation successful? Have they been involved in shaping the change?


People aren't simply recipients of change. They should help drive it.


If you give people time, involve them early and recognise their contribution, you may discover they have valuable ideas about how the organisation should evolve.


Too often, change becomes another responsibility added to an already busy working day. People are expected to maintain their existing workload while simultaneously delivering transformation, without sufficient time to prepare, learn or contribute.


Think about elite military teams or the fire service. They spend considerable time training and practising for situations that may require rapid action. Their preparation helps them perform when it matters.


Businesses, by contrast, can sometimes expect people to adapt to major change with little more than a few additional hours alongside their normal responsibilities.

We need a better balance. If transformation matters, people need the opportunity to prepare for it and play a meaningful role in delivering it.


From commercial intention to commercial impact

PJ : If there's one message you'd like senior leaders to take away from this conversation, what would it be?


Tim : Don't underestimate the value of curiosity, and don't underestimate the people who make your organisation work.


Commerciality isn't simply about managing costs, delivering budgets or selecting the right technology. It's about understanding value, asking better questions, making informed decisions and ensuring the organisation has the people and capabilities to deliver.


Leaders need to create an environment where people understand the bigger picture, feel able to challenge constructively and have the time and opportunity to contribute.


PJ Stevens - closing reflection

Tim's perspective highlights an important challenge for business leaders, organisations may have more potential to improve than their current performance suggests, but that potential won't be unlocked through strategy, technology or financial control alone.


It requires a shift in everyday thinking and behaviour.


When people understand how the business creates value, have the confidence to question how things are done and are given the space to contribute, commerciality becomes more than a specialist skill. It becomes part of the organisational culture.


For directors and senior leaders, the question is therefore not simply whether the business has a commercial strategy.


It's whether the organisation's everyday behaviours, leadership decisions and working environment enable people to turn that strategy into value.


Photograph of Tim Foster, ex BDO Partner, a very distinguished businessman in suit jacket and business shirt, wearing glasses. Interview with PJ Stevens about Commercial Leadership.
Photograph of Tim Foster, ex BDO Partner, a very distinguished businessman in suit jacket and business shirt, wearing glasses. Interview with PJ Stevens about Commercial Leadership.

 
 
 

Comments


Ready for the next step?

Connect with PJ Stevens

  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
bottom of page