Commercial leadership starts with Clarity
A conversation with Dr Michael McGrath
In boardrooms and leadership meetings, the phrase ‘we need to be more commercial’ is used almost as often as it is misunderstood. Yet despite its seeming popularity, few organisations have a shared understanding of what commerciality actually means, let alone how to develop it.
In this conversation, my friend and colleague Michael challenges many of the assumptions leaders make about commerciality. Rather than viewing it as a function, a department, or a set of financial measures, he argues that true commerciality is rooted in organisational alignment, culture, and the quality of questions leaders ask.
PJ : When a director says, ‘We need to be more commercial’, what do you think they really mean?
Michael:I’m not sure they always know themselves. There certainly isn’t a common, agreed definition of commerciality. When someone says, “We need to be more commercial”, my immediate response is: What exactly do you mean by that?
Do you mean we should be getting more value from our assets? Generating more revenue? Making better use of our people? Taking a different approach to identifying business opportunities?
The problem is that commerciality has become a very nebulous term. Because there isn’t a standard definition, when a CEO says it to a group of directors, every individual may interpret it differently. One person thinks it means revenue growth. Another thinks it means cost reduction. Someone else believes it’s about productivity or customer acquisition.
They may all be hearing something different, and they may all be wrong.
That’s why my answer is always the same, before you can become more commercial, you need to define what commerciality means in your organisation.
PJ : Is commerciality a department, a mindset, or a culture?
Michael: It’s definitely not a department. Part of it is a mindset, and ideally that mindset becomes embedded within the culture. But I don’t think commerciality can ever sit within one function or a small collection of teams.
For me, commerciality is fundamentally about optimising the resources available to the organisation. And when I say resources, I mean everything: people, technology, property, assets, information, relationships, all of it.
Commerciality is about finding the best opportunities to create value from those resources.
To achieve that, everyone has to be involved. It comes right back to culture. If I had to summarise it, I’d say commerciality is a mindset embedded in culture and enacted through every department of the organisation.
That’s why clarity matters so much. Before anything else, leaders need to be clear about what they mean and ensure the organisation shares that understanding.
PJ : How do you view the relationship between commerciality and systems thinking?
Michael: Systems thinking is essential, but it’s only part of the story. Systems thinking helps us understand how different parts of an organisation interact. It can help identify what a solution might look like and reveal unintended consequences that arise when functions operate in isolation.
But organisations are not just systems. They’re also cultures.
Culture is made up of all the intangible things that are difficult to measure directly. You know when a culture is healthy, and you know when something is missing, but it’s often hard to point to a specific metric that explains it.
Systems thinking is incredibly powerful, but it doesn’t tell the whole story. To build commercial capability, you need both systems thinking and a culture that enables people to work effectively across those systems.
PJ : You’ve developed go-to-market models, commercial frameworks and capability tools over many years. What are the biggest blockers preventing organisations from becoming truly commercial?
Michael: The biggest challenge is fragmentation. You can call them gaps, barriers, silos, disconnections, but they all amount to the same thing. They exist between functions, between teams and often between organisational levels.
Different parts of the organisation end up pursuing different priorities and different interpretations of success.
I worked with one organisation that stood out because managers would actually be challenged if they made a decision that was optimal for their department but sub-optimal for the wider business. That was seen as a development issue.
Most organisations don’t do that.
Naturally, people want to defend their teams. They want to optimise performance within their own area of responsibility. That feels right and often feels like good leadership. But organisations also need people to think beyond their immediate boundaries.
When fragmentation takes hold, whether organisationally, operationally or technologically, you create competing priorities, competing initiatives and poor information flow. You also create different interpretations of what the organisation is trying to achieve.
An organisation can be full of highly experienced, intelligent people making good decisions for their individual areas. But if those decisions are disconnected from one another, the organisation as a whole suffers.
No organisation will ever achieve perfect alignment, but the closer you can get to breaking down those barriers and creating a shared understanding of goals, the more commercial the organisation becomes.
That’s the universal challenge.
PJ : When you’ve worked with highly commercial leaders, what do they consistently do differently?
Michael: The best commercial leaders ask great questions. Commercial leadership is less about personally knowing all the answers and more about consistently asking the right questions.
As organisations grow, no leader can possibly hold all the knowledge required to make every decision. Even in relatively small businesses, the complexity becomes too great.
That means leaders cannot rely on their own expertise alone.
There’s also another challenge. Whenever there is a degree of power distance, people naturally become inclined to agree with the leader. They may support an idea because it came from the leader rather than because it has been properly tested.
The role of a commercial leader is to challenge assumptions through questioning. If someone proposes a new technology, for example, ask:
Why is this the right technology?
How will we test it?
How does it support our broader objectives?
How will we measure success?
The purpose is not simply to gather information. Asking questions forces people to articulate their thinking.
Very often, people discover weaknesses or opportunities in their own logic while explaining it. The act of answering the question improves the quality of thinking.
That’s why questioning matters at every level of the organisation.
PJ : What role does culture play in commercial success?
Michael: A huge one. People need to feel safe to ask questions, challenge assumptions and raise concerns.
I’m not talking about obstructive behaviour or asking questions purely to score points. I’m talking about genuine curiosity and constructive challenge.
Too many organisations unintentionally create environments where people learn that speaking up isn’t worth the effort. Sometimes they feel ignored. Sometimes they feel penalised.
Once that happens, ideas stop flowing. Innovation slows down, knowledge sharing declines and opportunities are missed.
Culture is often overlooked because it’s difficult to measure, but it’s incredibly important. In many ways, culture is the oil that keeps the organisational engine running smoothly.
Without it, even the best strategies struggle to gain traction.
PJ : If you were advising a leadership team tomorrow, what would be the first step they should take towards becoming more commercially minded?
Michael: Have an honest, adult conversation about what commerciality actually means.
Ask yourselves:
What are we trying to achieve?
Do we need to think differently about business opportunities?
Do we need to change how we use our assets?
Do we need to improve how we make decisions?
The reality is that commerciality probably involves all of those things.
But until leaders create a shared understanding, people will continue working from different assumptions.
Everything starts with clarity. Because before an organisation can become more commercial, it first needs to agree on what commercial means.
____________________________
Key takeaway for Senior Leaders
Michael’s central message and insights are that commerciality is not a function, a framework or a financial metric. It is organisational alignment in action.
My view is that most commercial organisations are not necessarily those with the best sales teams or the most sophisticated financial models. They are the organisations that:
Share a clear understanding of what success looks like.
Break down silos and fragmentation.
Optimise resources across the whole business, not just within functions.
Create cultures where challenge and questioning are encouraged.
Develop leaders who ask better questions rather than assuming they already have the answers.
In other words, commerciality begins with clarity. And clarity, as Michael argues, is ultimately a leadership responsibility.
__________________________________________________________________________________
CTA for Leaders - Turn commerciality from a buzzword into a business advantage
If the conversation I had with Michael resonate with you, ask yourself a simple question -
Can everyone in your organisation define commerciality, and in the same way?
For many leadership teams, the answer is no. Different functions pursue different priorities, silos emerge, decision making becomes disjointed, fragmentation grows and opportunities to create value are missed.
The good news is that commerciality is not a mystery. It can be defined, aligned, embedded and measured.
We help leadership teams to -
✅ Create a shared definition of commerciality that fits their organisation
✅ Break down functional silos and align teams around common goals
✅ Identify barriers that prevent effective teamwork, problem solving and progress
✅ Develop commercially minded leaders who ask better questions and make better decisions
✅ Build cultures where challenge, curiosity and collaboration drive performance
✅ Design practical commercial frameworks, go-to-market strategies and capability programmes that create measurable value
Whether you're looking to improve growth, optimise resources, strengthen leadership capability or create greater organisational alignment,much of it starts with clarity.
If your organisation is talking about becoming ‘more commercial’ but struggling to define what that actually means in practice, let's have a conversation. Together, we can turn commerciality from an aspiration into a capability.
Get in touch to discuss how we can help your leadership team define, align and embed commercial thinking across your organisation
